Considering the Major Dramatic Question of Marsha Norman’s ‘Night, Mother is no easy feat. The
question of whether Jessie will kill herself would seem to be the obvious
choice. However, in my opinion, ‘Night,
Mother is more than a play about suicide: it’s a play about a mother and
daughter’s struggle to make a connection. So, I propose that the major dramatic
question of the play could be, “Will Jessie and her mother make a connection?”
Making a connection can entail several things. First, this
includes Mama’s struggle to understand why Jessie has to leave. At first Mama
can’t fathom why Jessie would plan to kill herself if she feels fine and
rational. Mama later blames herself, still not understanding her daughter’s
rationale. However, at the end of the show, Mama seems to have a clearer
understanding of why Jessie did it. She says, “I didn’t know! I was here with
you all the time. How could I know you were so alone?”
Making a connection can also include the Mama’s struggle to
accept Jessie’s wishes. At first Mama is vehemently opposed to Jessie’s plan. Until
the end Mama does everything in her power to make Jessie stay. However, after
Jessie kills herself, Mama obeys Jessie’s last wishes by calling Dawson and
grabbing the chocolate pan that Jessie wanted her to wash. Earlier in the show,
Mama refused to wash the pan, but at the end, she seems to obey Jessie in
resignation.
In my opinion, Mama’s struggles to understand Jessie’s
decision and accept her wishes are the emotional core of the 'Night, Mother. These two
struggles show the MDQ at work and drive the show forward. The entire purpose
of Jessie’s telling her plan to her mother is to make a connection with her.
Jessie says, “It’s private. Tonight is private, yours and mine, and I don’t
want anybody else to have any of it.” Without this desire to connect, the play
would be significantly shorter or not exist at all.
i like how you made the major dramatic question lie within both characters and not just focus on one. I believe this is a great choice because the whole play jesse is trying to get mama to have one last moment (connection) with her before she dies. I also like this choice because jesse killing herself with effect mama, so the play should be looked at through the eyes of both characters and not focusing on one or the other more. I agree this type of question can drive the play forwards, yet also ends the play as it is answered.
ReplyDeleteI also second the previous comment. Including both characters in your MDQ is very nice, considering the plot only includes Mama and Jessie. The MDQ as "making a connection" is very understandable from all the examples you used. We as the audience, along with Mama, want to see that connection between them and Jessie change her mind. Although, neither Mama or the audience see that happen.
ReplyDelete